Everything is Not Fine

This past week has been an interesting time to be a Syracuse University alumnus. In the wake of the Penn State scandal, we had three different people step forward and accuse long-time Syracuse Orange men’s basketball assistant coach Bernie Fine of molestation. The university first put Fine on administrative leave during the pending investigation and then eventually when the media and community pressure grew to be too much, they fired him.

Head coach Jim Boeheim originally stood by his friend and went on the attack against the accusers saying,  “I believe they saw what happened at Penn State and they are using ESPN to get money.” Regardless of how this situation bears out and what, if any, allegations are found to be true, statements like that can be tremendously hurtful for people who have gone through similar situation. Statements that blame the victim minimize a very real pain and discredit traumatic experiences. (To his credit, Boeheim has since apologized and expressed regret for his remarks.)

I don’t want to get into an accusatory argument of who knew what, said what and did what. There is going to be plenty of time for that in the days and weeks to come. I want to make this a broader conversation. Something that we have not spent nearly enough time talking about in the aftermath of Penn State and now Syracuse is how off-limits university athletic programs have been for so long. If there was more oversight of these teams and less of a willingness to look the other way when incidents arise, maybe individuals would not feel emboldened and take terrible actions. Coaches and players on these teams feel invincible.  I am a HUGE sports fan and I’m not trying to demonize athletes and coaches, but just because you can score a touchdown or dunk a basketball does not put you above repercussions.

So the question arises: what do we do about it? I think that players and coaches need to go through empowered bystander training so that they can learn what to do when someone on the team is doing something that they know is inappropriate or illegal. A lot of these athletes come out of a “no snitching” culture and unless schools emphasize the importance of bystanders taking action and preventing tragedies, nothing will change. School leaders, coaches and team captains have to set the tone for the rest of the team. People with credibility have to step forward and say, “if this were to happen in my locker room, this is what I would do and this is what I expect you to do. Nothing less will be tolerated.”

What do you think schools and communities need to do?


One thought on “Everything is Not Fine

  1. I’m glad you mentioned this. I have half a blog post written that I’m trying to finish about this very topic. I’m torn between wanting to hold people accountable and wanting to win a national championship again. I WILL say that, give the work Syracuse does with empowering first year students I was horribly disappointed about this.

    I think Don McPherson does a great job of being someone credible (in the realm of sports) and talking about the importance of being an empowered bystander. The question I see is maybe a step above your question, how did we get to this point when certain people in our society can be above the law and human decency?

    I think before we can think about what schools and communities need to do, there needs to be more done in the realm of professional sports to hold players accountable for their actions. College sports are bound by money and if nothing changes at the top, I don’t think anything will change at the bottom.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s